Hi cephers, At the CLT meeting today there's been agreement to *make Ceph API tests "required" *again for Pull Request to be merged: - The current approach (*"honoring the agreement not to merge failing PRs"*) is simply not working: PRs have been merged with API tests in red. While most of these are harmless due to random failures (*we are working to improve this*), other times API tests warned about real issues... which eventually slipped into the code. [1] <https://tracker.ceph.com/issues/47306> [2] <https://tracker.ceph.com/issues/45717> [3] <https://github.com/ceph/ceph/pull/36091> - The cost & risk of debugging issues a posteriori is usually higher than the pain of retriggering the API tests (*we are working to improve this*). - Ceph API tests, even with their downsides, are providing true integration testing at CI time: this doesn't simply mean complex unit tests or component testing, it means running a vstart Ceph cluster and actually testing RADOS, RBD, RGW, CephFS... *What does this mean?* If Ceph API tests are in green, great! It's not that hard to achieve: ~*75% PRs pass the Ceph API tests from the beginning.* [image: image.png] What if they *are NOT* passing? [image: image.png] From Github you may access Ceph API tests results in Jenkins by clicking in *"Details"* and you'll see a report: 1. The test may fail due to multiple causes: issues in a Jenkins node, Github repo fetching, "make" stage, ... (if this is the case you may easily retrigger the Ceph API test by adding a comment to the PR with the text "jenkins test api"). 2. If the failure actually happens as a result of the Ceph API tests themselves, the report will look like this <https://jenkins.ceph.com/job/ceph-api/2726/>: [image: image.png] From there: - You can quickly check whether this has already been reported <https://tracker.ceph.com/search?q=FAIL:%20test_all%20%28tasks.mgr.dashboard.test_rgw.RgwBucketTest%29&open_issues=1> (a known issue or a flapping test) or otherwise raise a new issue report <https://tracker.ceph.com/projects/mgr/issues/new?issue[subject]=FAIL:%20test_all%20%28tasks.mgr.dashboard.test_rgw.RgwBucketTest%29&issue[category_id]=182&issue[assigned_to_id]=&issue[description]=%3Cpre%3EPlease%20copy%20here%20the%20console%20error%20message%3C/pre%3E> . - If the failure looks like a flapping one, you may retrigger the tests. - If, however, the failure is caused by an intentional change in behaviour, please reach out to Dashboard team for help. *What may you expect from the Dashboard team?* - We are working to harden Ceph API tests, increase their coverage and make them more stable. You may check our backlog <https://pad.ceph.com/p/dashboard-api-test-improvements> of improvements. You are welcome to contribute with ideas or, even better, working code ;-) - We are monitoring every day how Ceph API tests are doing: failure rate, runtime, ... - You can find us in #IRC (#ceph-dashboard), Github (@ceph/dashboard), in this very mail-list or pinging us directly: Lenz (in CC) is the component lead, Laura (in CC too) is taking care of Dashboard QA, or myself. Kind regards, Ernesto
